I decided to stick with an Asus (pronounced uh-soos) motherboard and picked up their Z87-Plus. The board being replaced, the P6T, was also an Asus board. Come to think of it, so was its predecessor (the A8N-sli). Before that it was an Intel board. Even though I don't do much overclocking I love the attention to detail that Asus puts into its products. And its website is well organized - always easy to find drivers. A few years back a quick comparison of their website to the website of their competitors (Gigabyte, MSI, etc...) sent me flying into their arms. They're not the least expensive boards but I've had good experience with them.
I fallen in love with the front panel header connector they ship with their boards. You plug the front-panel connectors (power LED, reset switch, PC speaker, etc...) into the connector (pictured below) then plug the connector into the board. It's a lot easier to swap out motherboards because you don't have to reconnect the sometimes lilliputian shunts onto single pins.
|Front Panel Connector|
|CPU and stock fan|
|UEFI BIOS for Asus Z87-Plus|
|UEFI BIOS Confirmation Dialog (apologies for the fuzzy picture)|
As a pc hobbyist since the mid 90s it amazes me how much easier it has become to build your own PC. I haven't cut myself on an add-on card or connector in going on 10 years. :)